1

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe

*If you are new here, WELCOME! For Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas, I provide your book club with a brief summary, a recipe, and book club questions in that order!

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
French Toast Sandwich
French Toast Sandwich

Do you love small town romances? If so, then you’ll love Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas. The novel is the first in a new series by Jodi Thomas, who, if you don’t know, is the queen of Texas romance.

Her books, set in Texas, range from historical to contemporary, from series to stand alone books. While she primarily writes romance, several of her books also lean towards women’s fiction like The Widows of Wichita County and The Little Teashop on Main. She’s won three RITAs for her romance books, which led to her induction into the Romance Writers of America Hall of Fame (with only 17 other romance writers!).

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas

I should also note that, being a Texan myself, her characters ring very true to the Texan spirit. I’ve also had the privileged to meet and talk with Jodi Thomas several times and she is a lovely and genuine person.

All that said, if you or your book club is looking for a romance to read, please check out her romances. Whatever you are looking for, I’m sure she has something in that vein. I particularly love small town romances, so Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe was a good fit! Plus, I love the title! Before I get to the recipe and book club questions, let me share a little bit more about this Jodi Thomas book.

The novel centers on a small town mayor who needs protection from a scandal threatening to destroy her career and reputation. Insert a State Trooper who’s vying for a promotion to Texas Ranger to protect her. Add a cast of quirky, but well-meaning characters, and you’ve got the equation for a winner.

In many of her contemporary romances, Jodi Thomas includes multiple romances occurring throughout the novel in addition to the primary story. Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe is no different. There are actually three romantic story lines through the book, with the above mentioned being the primary one. I will also note that this book, in particular, has just the right amount of spice, without including anything you’d feel bashful about giving your mother-in-law to read.

So, if you and your book club are looking for a new, fun read, look no further! Below I share a summary, a recipe and book club questions for Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas for your next meeting!

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe

Here’s a brief summary of Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas:

Piper Jane comes from a long line of Texas lawmen and she’s quick to take her place among them as a lawyer and the mayor of Honey Creek. When Colby, a State Trooper, comes to investigate the scandal plaguing her, she’s sure he’s not the type of man she would ever date. As the mystery comes to light, so do Piper’s true feelings and she begins to question whether or not her career really is all she needs.

For the Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe Recipe:

The novel includes several scenes with food. There are a few I consider quintessential Texan foods–like cherry limes, chicken fried steak, and tacos and beer. However, since the title of the book is Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe, I decided to create a breakfast dish.

In Chapter 17, Colby makes breakfast at the cafe. He says there’s only one thing he can cook–a bacon grilled cheese. I loved this scene and his can-do attitude.

After further reviewing the book, I also noted that Piper mentions the cafe has the best French toast around. So, I decided to combine the two into a French toast sandwich with bacon and sweet cream cheese! It’s a recipe that doesn’t use a frying pan to make french toast, but instead uses the oven, which makes serving a crowd MUCH easier.

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe
Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe

In case you aren’t feeling French toast, here are some other food suggestions from the pages of the book that you could use for your book club meeting:

  • Chapter 3 – Piper mentions the cafe serves the best French toast and Piper introduces Sam to Honey Creek and chicken fried steak
  • Chapter 17 – Colby makes breakfast at the cafe – grilled cheese with bacon. In addition, Piper has an omelet and coffee.
  • Chapter 24- Town square fair – lemonade, Lane family honey, fried Oreos, hot dogs, sweet potato fries with cheese, tacos and beer
  • Chapter 32- cherry limes, lemonade and cupcakes from Pecos and Kerri’s reception
  • Chapter 40- The widows feed Colby hummus and crackers and a sandwich

A few pointers for the French toast sandwich:

  • Make sure your baking pan is HOT and that you spray it liberally with Pam before you place the sandwiches onto the pan.
  • Work quickly. Preassemble ALL the sandwiches you are making and have them nearby, along with the bowl of eggs, milk, and maple.
  • Don’t oversoak the bread. Since you are going to work quickly, the speed will help you avoid oversoaking the bread. Just quickly dip each outer facing side of bread into the egg mixture and allow any extra to drip off.
  • The cooking time will depend on the type of bread you use. A thicker white bread, like I use, should cook in about the same time. Wheat bread will take longer and thinner white bread will take less time.
French Toast Sandwich
French Toast Sandwich

This sandwich is DELICIOUS. I couldn’t keep from taking several bites eating a whole sandwich before I took the pictures. This is definitely going on my menu of breakfast foods for the future.

And, even if you don’t love it, you will love this new, quick way to make French toast. The French toast comes out perfect, not soggy, which is my major complaint about French toast.

So, if you are looking for food suggestions for Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas, I think your book club will love this French Toast and Bacon Sandwich!

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions and Recipe

French Toast Sandwiches

Sweet cream cheese meets crispy bacon between two slices of French toast! You can’t go wrong with this breakfast treat!
Prep Time 10 mins
Cook Time 30 mins
Total Time 40 mins
Course Breakfast, Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 6
Calories 623 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 12 slices Bacon
  • 12 slices Texas Toast
  • 8 ounces cream cheese softened
  • ½ cup brown sugar
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 1 cup milk
  • 4 eggs
  • 1 tsp maple or vanilla

Instructions
 

For the bacon:

  • Place the strips of bacon on a parchment lined baking sheet.
  • Place the baking sheet in a cold oven, then set the temperature to 400 degrees.
  • Cook for 15-20 minutes to your desired crispiness.
  • Set aside to cool.

For the sandwiches:

  • Place a second baking sheet (large enough to hold six slices of bread) into the oven and preheat the oven to 450 degrees with the empty baking sheet inside. You are heating your pan in preparation of cooking the sandwiches.
  • In a medium bowl, mix the softened cream cheese, brown sugar, and vanilla.
  • In a separate bowl wide enough to dip your bread, mix the eggs, milk, and maple. *Vanilla can be substituted for maple.
  • Assemble the sandwiches.
  • a. Spread the cream cheese mixture on ONE side of every single piece of bread (you want lots of cream cheese on your sandwich!). The amount for each slice sound be about as much as peanut butter on a sandwich.
  • b. Place two strips of bacon on six of the slices.
  • c. Place the other six slices on top of the bacon covered bread to complete your sandwiches.
  • Once your pan is hot and the oven is ready, line your sandwiches up and place the bowl of egg mixture nearby.
  • Quickly pull the pan from the oven AND spray with Pam! This is crucial or your sandwiches will stick!
  • Quickly dip each side of every sandwich into the egg mixture and place onto the hot pan. You do don’t want to dunk the sandwich into the mixture but dip each side so that the mixture coats the bread but doesn’t soak it.
  • Place the pan into the oven and cook for 4-6 minutes. Carefully watch the bread for burning.
  • Flip the sandwiches after 4-6 minutes and cook the other side for 4-6 minutes more. Again, watch for burning.
  • Pull the sandwiches out of the oven and serve warm with maple syrup!

Notes

See the post above for tips and tricks!
Keyword Breakfast, Dessert, Sandwich

Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe by Jodi Thomas Book Club Questions:

*WARNING: May contain spoilers!

  1. Piper Jane comes from a long line of Texas lawmen and she’s quick to take her place among them as a lawyer and mayor. When Colby, a State Trooper, comes to investigate the scandal plaguing her, she calls him “self-assured, maybe a little dangerous. The kind of man she wouldn’t feel comfortable dating.” Why do you think that Piper is undeterred about running a town, but reserved when it comes to matters of the heart?
  2. Colby comes to Honey Creek for one reason—to earn a promotion to Ranger. He’s as career driven as Piper and he prefers his women easy to leave, but along the way that begins to change. What is it about Piper and Honey Creek that you think makes him want to change his plans?
  3. Sam has endured a lot of pain–from the London bombings to war to losing his love. He winds up in Honey Creek to try yet another avenue in hopes of finding himself again. It’s soon clear preaching is not his future, but through it he meets Anna. She’s a pint-sized pistol unafraid of shooting straight. How do you think Anna helped Sam discover his true calling?
  4. Anna is an eccentric and brash woman. Unlikely to take orders from anyone, she’s trying to single handedly solve all the problems in Honey Creek. But Sam surprises her. How do you think Sam helped Anna loosen her grip on the reigns just enough to allow him in?
  5. Pecos may not have much family, but he’s got his whole life ahead of him and big dreams. Why do you think he’s quick to stand by Kerri’s side through her ordeal? What characteristics of these two make you believe they aren’t just two dumb kids without a chance? Where do you think they’ll be in 5 years?
  6. The book features multiple romance story lines. Which story did you connect with the most and why?
  7. Were you kept guessing about Boone’s whereabouts the entire book? In the end why do you think he wanted to harm Piper? Do you think he wanted to destroy her happiness if he couldn’t have her? Were you glad Colby and Sam saved him? 
  8. We are introduced to a lot of Honey Creek characters in this book. Who was your favorite main character (Sam, Anna, Colby, Piper, Pecos, Kerri)? Who was your favorite secondary character (Mr. Winston, Digger, the Sherriff, etc.)?
  9. At the end of the book, we get a snippet of the next book in the series and see that Marcie will get a leading role and a chance at real love. Who would you like to see as main characters (romantic leads) in future books?
  10. Have you read any other Jodi Thomas books? Which was your favorite?

Have you read anything by Jodi Thomas? What did you think? What are some similar books you’ve read?

Until next time, Happy Reading!

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. In the event of a sale, I will be awarded a small commission (at no extra cost to you or the featured book’s author). All opinions are 100% mine and every book, unless otherwise noted, is handpicked by me to be featured on the site.

I was gifted an advance reader copy of Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe for my review.

Other Books by Jodi Thomas that you might enjoy!

Mallory
 

I’m Mallory Barnes, a fiction writer living in West Texas.My hope here is to encourage reading and discussion. In the digital age, we often live together so separately. Community and intellectual discussion are harder and harder to come by. I hope that Book Club Bites can help alleviate that by encouraging the birth and growth of book clubs.

  • […] All of Jodi Thomas’ books are set in Texas, so if this particularly story doesn’t sound like a fit, check out her long list of romances (some historical, some contemporary). You can also find a full review with discussion questions and a recipe for her latest release, Breakfast at the Honey Creek Cafe here. […]

  • >